We鈥檝e heard it before: The West just doesn鈥檛 have enough water to satisfy all the different demands on it. In Colorado, the majority of our water supply comes from mountainous snowpack, which melts each year to fill streambeds and reservoirs.
But could there be another way?
That鈥檚 what Christine Jacques, a listener in Golden, Colorado, wanted to know. She submitted a question as part of Curious Colorado, where we take questions from listeners and help track down answers.
Christine asked: 鈥淚s any research being done on creating water safely under laboratory conditions? And would it be considered artificial water? Would it be cleaner from the start than water from for example the South Platte which has to be treated before use?鈥�
We鈥檙e replicating all kinds of things in labs these days. So, why not water? On paper, it鈥檚 pretty simple: two parts hydrogen and one part oxygen. But for a relatively simple compound, it鈥檚 not so simple to replicate. If you need to brush up on your chemistry basics, Bill Nye the Science Guy can help.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wc-at5rzzDU
But rather than just consulting 90s TV shows to find the answer to whether or not we can make water in a lab, I run Christine鈥檚 question past Colorado State University chemistry professor Tony Rappe. He dives right in.
鈥淢aking water from, say, hydrogen, the big challenge with that is where does the hydrogen come from?鈥� he says.
According to Rappe, hydrogen is not in ready supply.
鈥淵ou can鈥檛 poke a hole in the ground and get it out like you can natural gas,鈥� Rappe says.
Most of the hydrogen gas we have is produced from methane. The way we process hydrogen made from methane now is an energy intensive process. It鈥檚 so energy intensive, that the final product would be really expensive.
The second way you could do it, Rappe says, would be to take water that we already have in abundance, like already used graywater or salty ocean water, and electrolyze it to generate hydrogen. Then scientists could recombine the hydrogen with oxygen, and voila, fresh water is formed.
鈥淒oing that would be about 1,000 times more energy intense than the most efficient way of getting at pure water,鈥� Rappe says.
So is there any way to get more fresh water into the dry, and highly populated areas of the West and take the burden off of existing supplies like the Colorado River?
鈥淭he least expensive way is desalination where you basically take brackish water, turn it into water vapor and recondense it,鈥� Rappe says.
Turning briny ocean water into something we can drink is already happening used and . Some desalination plants are operating, too. So far, it鈥檚 the most economic way to manufacture large amounts of clean water.
鈥淚t鈥檚 more expensive than just letting it rain,鈥� Rappe says. 鈥淏ut in dry places it could be a viable option.鈥�
But desalination has its drawbacks and critics. If not done carefully, environmentalists say intake pipes -- which suck ocean water into the facilities -- can harm sea life. They can get injured again when excess brine is pumped back into the ocean.
All that to say: It鈥檚 really hard to improve upon the natural water cycle.
鈥淭he best way to generate water is the way we currently do it,鈥� Rappe says. 鈥淚n the oceans the sun causes water to vaporize, turn into clouds, come over, condense and come down as clean rain.鈥�
It might be the most efficient way right now, but we don鈥檛 get to decide where it rains or snows, or how much of it comes down at any given time. Making up water shortages in a lab is enticing. But for now, we鈥檙e not able to cheaply produce enough of it to make a difference. Or, as Bill Nye put it in 1997:
鈥淭he ocean is made of H2O. You and I are full of H2O. It鈥檚 wild, it鈥檚 wonderful. It鈥檚 water!鈥�
If you have a question about water, 皇冠网址 wants to help answer it. to submit a question to Curious Colorado, or use the module below.
This story is part of a project covering the Colorado River, produced by 皇冠网址 and supported through a Walton Family Foundation grant. 皇冠网址 is solely responsible for
_
